Priests, Prophets, Pirates, and Pedestrians
Why rule-breakers, risk-takers, and pirate leaders are the key to startup success
“Early-stage startups are a lot like pirate ships. Pirates don’t convene a committee meeting to decide what to do—they strike quickly, break rules, and take risks. And you need this buccaneering spirit to survive when the cannonballs are flying and the odds are against you.”
– LinkedIn CEO and Founder Reid Hoffman
“Oh my God, when you’re a startup founder, it’s all pirates. Who joins a startup? Crazy people, because startups are so risky. They’ve got a chip on their shoulder. They’ve got something to prove. They don’t want rules.”
– MailChimp CEO and co-founder Ben Chestnut
A few weeks ago we discussed the power of ideas that are “unthinkable, unknowable, or unbelievable” (read the post here). We call these “Heretical Ideas” and believe that this way of thinking and questioning the world is incredibly important for developing truly radical innovation. At the early-stage, a heretical mindset provides strong signal for identifying high potential technology founders. When you combine heretical thinking with people who demonstrate powerful operating capabilities and the capability of acting independently, you end up with a Pirate Founder.
At a January 1983 off-site retreat while developing the first Macintosh computer, Steve Jobs famously declared “It’s better to be a pirate than to join the Navy.” This statement encapsulated a philosophy of agility, breaking away from corporate bureaucracy to innovate and move swiftly. Andy Hertzfeld, a member of that original Macintosh team, later explained that being a pirate meant being "audacious and courageous, willing to take considerable risks for greater rewards."
In this sense, Pirates are not rebels without a cause and they are not simply greedy. Rather they are passionate builders who reject the constraints of bureaucracy and authoritarianism and embrace their own skills, efforts, and agency. Pirates embody entrepreneurial spirit and a willingness to venture into uncharted territories trusting in their own abilities in the face of extraordinary risk. They are powerful operators who thrive when allowed to work independently.
Piracy is powerful because it is not a method or a motivation, it is a mindset. “The potential for riches was just an argument for the venture. But the real payoff was the pirate life itself.”
Piracy is powerful specifically because it is not a method or a motivation, it is a mindset. As TechCrunch Founder and CEO Michael Arrington noted, “The potential for riches was just an argument for the venture. But the real payoff was the pirate life itself.”
In the dynamic landscape of leadership, personalities and strategies vary widely, influenced by diverse motivations and goals. To simplify the complexity, we consider leaders as falling into one of four archetypal categories: Priests, Prophets, Pirates, and Pedestrians. Each persona plays a unique role in shaping our institutions and culture, and each is empowered or restricted in their preferred level of their independence and power. In our experience, it is the Pirates who drive the most successful outcomes in the chaotic environments typical of early-stage startups.
Leadership Archetypes Explained
Priests: Priests are the guardians of tradition and orthodoxy. Their mission is to uphold and reinforce the status quo, ensuring the continuity and stability of existing institutions. They operate under low agency and are institutional by nature, focusing on maintaining and enhancing structured systems already in place.
Prophets: Prophets serve as the moral compass of institutions, challenging the status quo when it fails to align with fundamental principles or visions. They often rise during times of perceived moral decay or institutional inadequacy. Prophets work within existing hierarchies but push for renewal and ethical realignment, making them somewhat disruptive but still tied to institutional frameworks.
Pirates: Pirates are the disruptors of the archetypal world who build outside of conventional systems. They operate with high autonomy and are highly disruptive, driven not by the desire to maintain or renew, but to overtake or outright plunder. They prioritize competence and creativity over credentials over consent. Pirates hijack existing resources and systems to create entirely new alternative authorities and institutions, embodying innovation and radical change.
Pedestrians: Pedestrians are the everyday individuals who prefer to stay on the sidelines of institutional conflicts. They are characterized by their passive approach to leadership and change, often motivated by maintaining personal peace rather than engaging in broader institutional or cultural battles. Pedestrians typically exhibit low autonomy and are not inherently disruptive, adhering instead to the path of least resistance.
Why Pirates Make Excellent Founders in Startup Technology Companies
Pirates, with their drive for independence and their powerful capabilities, are naturally suited to the world of startups, particularly in the fast-paced high risk technology sector. Among the attributes that make pirates particularly effective leaders and innovators in this context are:
Risk Tolerance: Pirates thrive in uncertain environments, making bold decisions that can lead to high rewards. Their willingness to take risks is essential in the fast-paced tech industry, where innovation often means venturing into uncharted waters.
Resourcefulness: Just as historical pirates were adept at utilizing whatever resources were available, modern-day pirate leaders excel at bootstrapping and leveraging limited resources to achieve their goals.
Visionary Thinking: Pirates are not just leaders; they are visionaries. They can see potential where others see obstacles, imagining new solutions and opportunities that disrupt industries and create new markets.
Agility: In a landscape that changes rapidly, the ability to pivot and adapt strategies is crucial. Pirate leaders are inherently agile, navigating changes in the market or technology with ease and foresight.
Unconventional Strategies: Pirates do not play by the rules; they rewrite them. In the tech industry, this ability to think outside conventional frameworks often leads to groundbreaking products and services.
Looking for Pirates
Understanding these leadership archetypes helps in identifying not just the roles individuals may play within organizations but also the potential for innovation and change they bring. Pirates embody the spirit of entrepreneurial ventures in the tech industry, driving progress with their bold, unconventional approaches. As the business landscape continues to evolve, recognizing and nurturing diverse leadership styles will be key to fostering environments where innovation can thrive.
In the intricate dance of leadership and innovation, understanding the varied personas—Priests, Prophets, Pirates, and Pedestrians—offers invaluable insights. These archetypes not only shape our institutions and societal frameworks but also define the trajectories of industries, particularly in the realm of technology.
As always, we love to partner with exceptional founders and innovative investors. Don’t hesitate to reach out.
Let’s build a better future.
Peter & Maggie
Love this